Did anybody (from the Winners' List) receive any feedback from the judges? I emailed Lowry asking what's going on -- I never got an answer ...
Feedback
Mar, 01/02/2011 - 08:29
Feedback
Para obtener más información sobre las optimizaciones del compilador, consulte el aviso sobre la optimización.
- Inicie sesión para comentar
Mar, 01/02/2011 - 11:57
So I finally got
(10 mins ago) the so-called (4 lines!!!) feedback. One line says: Basically incomprehensible. I couldn't figure out how to
even move a piece on the chessboard.
Well, Mr.
gENIUS, as any toddler knows, there are 2 (TWO!!!) possibilities (not to
mention that everything is clearly explained in the Abstract and Tutorial: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XIXcd4al6kw):
left-click and left-click OR left-click and right-click. If you couldnt figure
that out then no McDonalds will ever hire you to flip the burger; who hired you
as an expert at Intel is beyond me
- Inicie sesión para comentar
Mié, 02/02/2011 - 05:34
Dude you are a bit too harsh, they did check a lot of games.
I got mine with mixedreviews,wonder who said what ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HO776JWJOqY&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL
http://www.yoyogames.com/games/147096-solar-conflict
Tell me what you think of the game!
Gamename: Solar Conflict
Feedback from Judging Panel:
Nice explosions. Nice retro feel.
This retro game was a lot of fun! The AI might be a bit too tough for the tutorial. I'll play this one again. No sound, alas, or it would have scored better.
This is a rough little compilation of a few hit products. As an idea it is more fleshed than as a demo. But it is a good idea.
Controls are wonky, key layout isn't friendly, ships are too slow and lumbering for dodging to work. Everything meaningful and difficult about a game like this remains to be done.
- Inicie sesión para comentar
Mié, 02/02/2011 - 07:53
yeah man, your stuff is OK (but hey, explosions with no
sound?!), although far from being original. But BilliChess is not only 100%
original, but also the smartest* game in the history of video games. For a
judge that was supposed to read the Abstract and check the Tutorial on
YouTube (the link for the Tutorial was provided in the Abstract) to say "Basically incomprehensible. I
couldn't figure out how to even move a piece on the chessboard." is
absolutely unacceptable. Many people played BilliChess (the MP version is up and
running) and nobody complained but that expert
*
Chess is the game of Kings and Queens, widely considered the most intelligent
game. A game of chess with an (intelligent) extra-challenge cant but be the
smartest game in the history of video games. Why did BilliChess deserve that
comment from that expert is beyond me